Bagel Island Cafe in Big Pine Key

Absolutely love this place!! Perfect for a quick, healthy breakfast, & coffee. Friendly and helpful staff. Clean, quiet atmosphere.

Great food and atmosphere 😄

LOVE this place!!Great food, clean little place, outstanding customer service best describe this place. They should be open 7 days a week so better serve their customers.

Love love love their bagels!! Their lox bagel is fabulous and I am not the biggest fan of smoked salmon. Definitely a place to grab some good food if you want a nice lunch or breakfast.

Great service. Very friendly owners. Food is simple and good

Cute little local bagel shop. Great bagels

Not only are the bagels awesome, the staff is super friendly!!

Great sandwiches and good prices. I stopped here on my way to visit the blue hole.

The BEST bagels and croissants ever. The service is a little slow, but WELL worth the wait. The Beef Bomber is amazing, all the specialty cream cheeses are also very tasty....Keep them coming.....

Good plan e to eat and quite friendly!!

We love this place! Best grilled blueberry muffin my wife and I have ever tasted, and such a nice staff. We used to frequent Big Pine Key from Orlando, but have since moved away from Florida. Haven’t been in years, but we hope they are still around and kickin when we return.

Great bagels and Coffee too

A gem of a place to find. Awesome lox and bagel sandwich!

Nice little bagel shop in a mall. Bagel was very decent as was the bacon, egg and cheese on it. Excellent coffee along with a friendly staff and customers! Small place with a few tables plus takeout. Plenty of parking. I have not tried the lunch sandwiches but the menu sounds good.

Best bagels in the keys. This place has been here forever and they know how to make the best breakfast sandwich!

Great service, quality ingredients and yummy sandwiches!

Very friendly place. Bagels were quality.

Wonderful food, staff, and great prices! Children and I had a great time!

Had a very nice and authentic tasting Cuban sandwich and a tasty smoothie. Reasonable prices, will return many times

Absolutely delicious sandwiches. Bagel sandwich was excellent and my hubby's sandwich came on a roll that was so fresh and soft.

Fresh bagels and coffee . I had the bagel suage egg and cheese bagel with the hazelnut coffee . Delish!!my daughter and brother had the vanilla shake . Best shake ever!!

Just moved to the area. I was very happy to find this place and it actually be good! Clean inside with a great menu of breakfast and lunch. Iced chai latte is delicious. Prices are very reasonable and staff was timely and friendly. You can even buy day old bagels (bags) for $2.50. This will for sure be a place my husband and I eat at weekly.

If you're going for the bagels, they are obviously made from scratch and DELICIOUS! Lots of cream cheese and super fluffy! However I was not a fan of the staff, make me feel rushed and nervous when ordering and was no help. Unless you can pay in cash you have to spend 10 dollars to pay with card which really wouldn't be much of a problem. They also serve other made from scratch breakfast foods which I did not try but looked very good! Overall, food was really good but staff was a disappointment.

Nice place. Great coffee, love the sesame bagels

Our first time visiting the Keys and we had a wonderful time! We were searching for a good casual place for coffee and breakfast - we were really craving bagels! Found this place online and decided to head on over. Relaxed and welcoming atmosphere, delicious flavors of coffees, and warm and fresh bagels with several flavors of cream cheese! It seemed to be a busy place, with people greeting each other like old friends, chatting with the owner and ordering their "regular breakfast". So glad we found this little yet enjoyable Bagel Shoppe, we will be back!

Awsome

Top notch

Loved it. Charming little coffee shop on Big Pine.

Small bagel and coffee shop. Excellent service and creative menu. We even saw a key deer outside the window. Bagels are fresh and lots of interesting sandwiches. I liked my sandwich, bagel with lots of good veggies. Nice place to stop for lunch when shopping at Winn Dixie, at same shopping center.

I love the toasted asiago bagel with egg, bacon and provalone...add a cup of coffee for a great breakfast to start your day. :)

Great bagels

Great coffee and fresh blueberry muffins

We love this place for a quick bite to eat. Located in a hidden corner in the Big Pine Key Winn Dixie Shopping Plaza, the bagels are freshly made an can be loaded with a seemingly endless list of goodies. We like the breakfast options best. Huge menu for a small place. It can be busy and the seating is limited.

Great little cafe, open early at 7AM most mornings. The staff was very friendly which was great. Prices, in my opinion, are really good for breakfast and coffee options and then pretty typical for lunch options. Regardless, the food and drink were great quality, and I would recommend for either breakfast or lunch. *Note: the shop prefers to use cash under $10 if possible, so think ahead. They won't deny your sale if you don't have cash, but it's always nice to support local businesses through little things like using cash for small purchases.

Great place to grab a coffee and bagel while driving along US 1.

My favorite breakfast and lunch spot!! Always very friendly and efficient. Very clean and comfortable in there small dining area. The food is fresh and they only serve quality products. Oh yeah and the best coffee in town, I try and go every morning for some. Great prices great service and great food are hard to find these days!!

Best bagel I have ever had, plain, toasted.

Bagel sandwich was good, place was full of people but sandwiches came quick. Iced coffee was good. We'll be back!

Perfect little place for breakfast or lunch. Have a broad menu of sandwiches, bagels, salads or pulled pork/hamburger if that's what you're craving. Nice people, great service.

Excellent service great food and fresh bagels every time. Went here 3 mornings in a row while in the Keys on vacation. Even at 12 noon bagels taste like they’re fresh out of oven. Thank you!

Food was fine, guy that took my order had an attitude. Apparently it's offensive when asked what type of bagel you want to say "regular", instead of "plain." As if regular would mean anything other than plain. I suggest a lesson in common sense and manners for the little man behind the counter.

Recently discovered bagel shop and I can tell you , you must stop by and try fresh bagels , sandwiches and more . This is a local honey spot . I love this place , food is melting in your mouth .

Good food, but if you call ahead, they still dont make it till u get there.

Great place to take a break up your drive. Not fancy but very cute with a deep menu and everything we tried was delicious.

Really Good bagels

This place is a joke. I called to place an order for 5 subs. Everyone wants something different. So the lady said she would have to call me back in 5 mins to get my order. I have never called a restaurant/ “sandwich shop” and they told me they would call me back to get my order. I couldn’t help but to laugh 😂 Well never got a call back.

Very friendly people! Good sandwiches!

espresso was incredible, bagles wre crunchy outside and airy inside, tasted excellent.

very delicious milkshakes and food very good

The family and I went here for breakfast. We didn’t have much time so we needed to be quick. We ordered all types of different things. Several bagels, a cinnamon roll, bacon and egg on toast, vanilla latte, frozen vanilla frappe, and a regular coffee.Overall, the food was decent, enough to hold you over until lunch, but it’s nothing special. The inside is small and has barely enough seating. The menu is varied, which is nice. They also serve lunch. The staff was friendly. It’s a good spot to go if you need a basic breakfast to get you through a few hours.